Solar industry beats Qld in red tape battle
Liam Walsh AFR Jun 25, 2019
The solar industry has won a battle against a Queensland law requiring licensed electricians to install panels on large-scale projects, a regulation they said was not about safety but about placating unions.
Queensland’s Court of Appeal on Tuesday dismissed an application by the government to enforce a new regulation that required the use of licensed electricians on projects such as solar farms.
The Palaszczuk government had introduced the regulation in May this year, arguing that serious risks of electrical shock loomed for people installing panels at large-scale facilities.
Businesses had argued that the work could be safely conducted by trained labourers. Then in that same month, Brigalow Solar Farm – a proposed 34 megawatt project in southern Queensland designed to power the equivalent of 11,300 homes – successfully challenged the new regulation in Queensland’s Supreme Court.
The government subsequently appealed that ruling, only for that challenge to be dismissed with costs by the Court of Appeal on Tuesday.
The decision partly flowed around definitions of “electrical work”. The Electrical Safety Act in defining “work” carved out activities such as fixing equipment in place if the task did not involve connecting the device to an electricity supply.
“The act comprehensively defines the work for which an electrical licence is required such as to leave no room for modification by delegated legislation,” Justice Hugh Fraser wrote in a decision backed by Justice Philip McMurdo and Justice David Boddice.
The new regulation “would involve ‘a new step in policy’ which cuts across that aspect of the act by requiring a licence for work that is not ‘electrical work’”, the ruling said.
Brigalow Solar Farm’s Lane Crockett described the decision as a “relief”, with panels able to be installed by trained labourers and licensed electricians still doing the electricity connections.
“This gives us the certainty we need to move forward, hiring the workers we need to keep building this solar farm,” he said. Mr Crockett is head of renewables for Impact Investment Group, which manages the fund that owns Brigalow Solar Farm.
Jack Hooper of electrical services provider Gem Energy also welcomed the decision.
“It will … decrease the bottleneck the industry faces with quality tradespeople,” he told The Australian Financial Review. “Our biggest challenge right now is to find skilled subcontractors.”
Mr Hooper argued one problem had been that a shortage of qualified electricians existed, so requiring only such people to do installations would lead to a slowdown in projects.
He also said costs would have increased between 10 per cent and 20 per cent on solar panel installations for commercial rooftops – such as for shopping centres. A 200 kilowatt system for instance, could cost an additional $30,000 on a $300,000 job, he estimated.
“Our business would have been massively impacted,” he said.
Mr Hooper also argued that it was unnecessary red tape and trained labourers could do the work safely. “It was never about safety,” he said.
Clean Energy Council chief executive Kane Thornton said industry “should never have had to go through the courts to resolve something that could easily have been worked out with a full and proper consultation process”.
Some industry figures suspect the regulation was a move to placate unions.
But the Queensland government has been adamant safety was the driving concern.
“We introduced these regulations following advice from an expert safety panel,” Industrial Relations Minister Grace Grace said in announcing the appeal last month. “When it comes to electrical safety there are no second chances.”
Electrical Safety Commissioner Greg Skyring also said at the time that “contrary to some of the commentary I’ve seen … these risks are very real and very serious”.
Ms Grace’s office is preparing an announcement to respond to the latest setback.
Energy Stuff specialises in Residential Solar with emphasis on Repairs, Replacements and upgrades. We also provide new systems, battery storage, Small Commercial, Off-Grid systems and smart monitoring systems. Energy Stuff is a Clean Energy Council Member and only uses CEC accredited installers. We fully comply with the Victorian Govt. Solar Rebate Program and we are supporting clients in their applications to the new scheme starting July 1st 2019.
For further information please call us on 1300 656 205 or go to our website at http://www.energystuff.com.au
Posted on 27 Jun 2019
Latest NewsMore News
China remains the world’s worst polluter but did you know it’s also a leader in renewable energy?
By Christina Zhou - ABC News - 2 July 2019 Shanghai, one of the world's most populous cities, will today enact strict green policies limiting disposable tak...More
The US produced more energy from renewable sources than from coal for the first time ever in April – despite President Trump pledging to ‘bring coal back’
By Danyal Hassain - Daily Mail Australia - 27 June 2019 In April, for the first time ever, the US produced more energy from renewable sources than from coal...More
Australia’s still building 4 in every 5 new houses to no more than the minimum energy standard
By Trivess Moore, Michael Ambrose & Stephen Berry - The Conversation New housing in Australia must meet minimum energy performance requirements. We ...More